Homemade Spicy Dutch Eggnog Recipe: A Festive Holiday Cocktail with a Unique Twist

Discover the ultimate homemade eggnog recipe with a delightful Dutch twist. This spicy, easy-to-make alcoholic beverage is incredibly delicious and perfect for holiday gatherings, blending traditional holiday cheer with unique European flavors.

There’s a special kind of excitement that builds as the holiday season approaches. Suddenly, certain festive delights appear everywhere, from social media feeds to cozy gatherings, inspiring home cooks and cocktail enthusiasts alike. For me, a few Christmases ago, this phenomenon was all about eggnog. Every English and American blog I encountered seemed to feature this traditional Christmas drink, sparking an undeniable urge within me to try my hand at making it. I thought to myself, this is a clear sign! It’s time to bring this classic holiday spirit into my home kitchen and craft a version that truly speaks to me.

However, living in the Netherlands, readily available, store-bought eggnog isn’t a common sight. This scarcity, rather than being a deterrent, became an exciting challenge. As I delved into the ingredients of traditional eggnog – eggs, cream, sugar, and spirits – a familiar local treat immediately came to mind: advocaat. This rich, creamy, and distinctively Dutch liqueur shares a wonderful foundation with eggnog, making it the perfect, unexpected starting point for my own unique creation. I decided to embrace this local gem, infusing it with a carefully selected blend of warm, inviting spices, additional complementary spirits, and other delightful elements to create a truly special holiday drink.

The result? Absolutely splendid! A velvety smooth, perfectly spiced, and wonderfully warming concoction that quickly became a personal favorite. I even had enough left over to chill in the refrigerator, ready to share with friends later that evening – and it tasted even better after the flavors had a chance to meld. I always love to kick off our dinner parties with a special, handcrafted cocktail, and this homemade spicy Dutch eggnog is precisely the right choice to set a festive and memorable mood. It’s a guaranteed conversation starter and a delicious way to celebrate the season.

The Dutch Secret: Elevating Eggnog with Advocaat

For those unfamiliar, advocaat is a traditional Dutch alcoholic beverage that is quite unique. It’s essentially a thick, creamy, custard-like liqueur made primarily from egg yolks, sugar, and brandy (or sometimes grain alcohol). With its vibrant yellow color and wonderfully smooth texture, it’s often enjoyed as a dessert liqueur, sometimes spooned straight from the glass, or used creatively as a topping for ice cream, pastries, and even coffee. Its rich, eggy profile and inherent sweetness make it a natural, albeit ingenious, substitute for the egg-and-cream base found in many classic eggnog recipes. By using advocaat, we not only significantly simplify the preparation process – eliminating the need to temper eggs and cook a custard from scratch – but we also introduce a distinctive depth of flavor and a silky smoothness that is truly unparalleled. This isn’t just an eggnog; it’s a celebration of Dutch culinary heritage blended seamlessly with a beloved global holiday tradition, offering a rich, ready-made base that’s both authentic and incredibly convenient.

Crafting Your Festive Cocktail: The Perfect Blend of Spirits and Spices

Beyond the luscious advocaat, this recipe calls for a carefully curated selection of spirits to build a robust and complex flavor profile that tantalizes the palate. We combine whisky for its warming, slightly smoky notes, Kahlua for a delightful hint of coffee and underlying sweetness, and rum to add a touch of Caribbean warmth, vanilla, and deep, molasses-like undertones. This trio creates a harmonious alcoholic base that complements the richness of the advocaat beautifully, transforming it into a truly sophisticated and multi-layered holiday drink. The interplay between these spirits ensures that each sip is an experience in itself, offering both familiarity and a subtle complexity.

The magic, however, truly comes alive with the addition of freshly grated spices. A medley of cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves is crucial to achieving that quintessential cozy, festive aroma and taste that define holiday drinks. Each spice contributes its unique warmth and aromatic complexity: cinnamon brings a sweet, woody note; nutmeg offers a rich, musky warmth; and cloves deliver a pungent, sweet, and aromatic kick. Together, they evoke powerful memories of winter evenings, crackling fireplaces, and joyful holiday cheer. The simplicity of whisking these high-quality ingredients together means that a truly exceptional and deeply flavorful holiday cocktail is just minutes away, ready to be shared and enjoyed.

Presentation Matters: Tips for Serving Your Homemade Eggnog

A delicious, handcrafted drink deserves an equally beautiful presentation, transforming a simple beverage into an artful experience. One of my favorite and most effective ways to elevate this spicy Dutch eggnog is by adding a glistening sugar rim to the serving glasses. This technique not only adds a touch of elegance and visual appeal but also enhances the overall sensory experience with a subtle, delightful sweetness as you take your first sip. Imagine the inviting, golden hue of the eggnog shimmering against a sparkling, sugar-coated rim – it’s a sight that promises a delightful taste and sets a luxurious tone for your gathering. Below, you’ll find detailed tips on how to achieve this perfect rim, along with other invaluable advice to make your homemade eggnog truly stand out and impress your guests.

• The Golden Sugar Rim: An Elegant Touch: To create an elegant and visually appealing sugar rim, first, gently pour a small amount of your prepared eggnog into a shallow dish. Dip the top edge of your serving glass into this eggnog, just enough to moisten the rim. Immediately after, dip the moistened rim into a separate shallow dish filled with fine sugar or light brown sugar. Ensure an even coating, and the sugar will adhere, creating a beautiful golden sparkle that perfectly complements the drink’s rich color and adds a pleasant sweetness to each sip. This simple step is a game-changer for presentation and enhances the overall drinking experience.
• Freshly Grated Nutmeg is Unbeatable: While pre-ground nutmeg offers convenience, freshly grated nutmeg provides an incredibly superior flavor and aroma. The essential oils, which carry much of the spice’s character, are far more potent and vibrant when released just before serving. If you can, invest in a whole nutmeg and a small grater. You’ll notice an immense difference in the depth, warmth, and vibrancy of the spice notes not just in this eggnog, but in all your culinary creations. Grate it directly over each serving for maximum impact and an intoxicating aroma.
• Versatile Kahlua Alternatives: If Kahlua isn’t readily available or you prefer a different coffee liqueur, there are excellent alternatives. You can easily substitute it with other popular coffee liqueurs such as Tia Maria, Sheridan’s, or even a good quality Patron XO Cafe. For a non-alcoholic coffee note, a dash of strong, cold-brew coffee concentrate mixed with a little sugar and perhaps a neutral spirit could work in a pinch, though the overall flavor profile might vary slightly. The goal is to retain that subtle yet impactful coffee essence that adds a beautiful layer of depth to the advocaat and other spirits.
• Embrace Full Winter Spice Blends: For an even more intense and cohesive winter flavor experience, consider substituting the individual cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves with 3 teaspoons of a high-quality gingerbread spice blend. These pre-mixed blends often contain a harmonious mix of ginger, allspice, cardamom, and other warming spices, which will infuse your eggnog with an unmistakably festive and complex character. It’s a fantastic shortcut to achieving a deeply spiced flavor profile without needing to measure out multiple individual spices.
• Creative Uses for Leftover Eggnog: Don’t Waste a Drop! Should you miraculously find yourself with any leftover homemade eggnog (a rare occurrence, perhaps, given how delicious it is!), absolutely do not let it go to waste! It’s incredibly versatile and can be repurposed into a variety of delicious treats. Use it to prepare a creamy, decadent pudding, a luxurious homemade ice cream, or a moist and flavorful cake. A splash can transform a simple cup of morning coffee into a gourmet holiday treat, or elevate a plain milkshake into a rich, indulgent indulgence. You can even use it as a base for French toast batter for an extra special holiday breakfast or brunch!
• Experiment with Rum Varieties: The recipe suggests rum, but the specific type of rum you choose can significantly alter the final taste profile of your eggnog. A dark, aged rum will lend deeper, more complex notes of caramel, vanilla, and oak, adding a layer of sophistication. A golden or spiced rum will introduce additional aromatic spices, enhancing the overall festive character. Conversely, a lighter rum might offer a cleaner, more vibrant kick, allowing the advocaat and other spices to shine more prominently. Consider your preference and explore different varieties to find your perfect balance.

Preparation and Storage Tips for Your Dutch Eggnog

To ensure your homemade spicy Dutch eggnog remains delicious, safe, and retains its inviting texture, proper preparation and storage are essential. Adhering to these simple guidelines will help you maximize its enjoyment:

• Optimal Refrigeration for Freshness: You can safely store this homemade eggnog in an airtight container in the refrigerator for 2 to 3 days. The alcoholic content certainly aids in its preservation, but because advocaat is an egg-based liqueur, it’s always best to consume it fresh for optimal flavor, consistency, and food safety. Before serving any stored eggnog, always give it a good stir or a gentle shake, as some natural separation of ingredients may occur over time.
• Why Freezing is Not Recommended: It is strongly advised not to freeze your homemade eggnog. The delicate emulsion of eggs, dairy (from the advocaat), and alcohol can break down irrevocably during the freezing and thawing process. This will almost certainly result in an undesirable, grainy, separated, or watery texture that compromises the smooth, creamy consistency that makes eggnog so enjoyable. To preserve the luxurious mouthfeel and rich flavor, stick strictly to refrigeration for storage.

More Festive Drink Ideas to Explore

If you’ve thoroughly enjoyed crafting and savoring this unique spicy Dutch eggnog, you might be keen to explore other festive beverages to brighten your holidays or special occasions. Expanding your repertoire of homemade cocktails and warm drinks can add an extra layer of magic to any gathering. Here are a few related recipes that offer different flavors and experiences, perfect for expanding your home bar and delighting your guests throughout the colder months:

📖 Recipe

RECIPE CARD

Spicy Eggnog, The Dutch Way

Andréa

This super easy and utterly delicious homemade spicy eggnog recipe features a unique Dutch twist, using traditional advocaat for a rich and creamy base. It’s the perfect alcoholic holiday cocktail for festive gatherings.

5 of 3 votes

Print Recipe
Pin Recipe

Cook Time

10 minutes
mins

Total Time

10 minutes
mins

Course
Drinks, Cocktail

Cuisine
American, Dutch

Servings

4
persons

Calories

387
kcal

Cook Mode

Prevent your screen from going dark

Ingredients

Spicy Eggnog

• ▢ 500 mL advocaat
• ▢ 125 mL whisky
• ▢ 125 mL Kahlua
• ▢ 125 mL rum
• ▢ 1 teaspoon cinnamon , grated
• ▢ 1 teaspoon nutmeg, grated

Rim and Garnish (Optional)

• ▢ 1 teaspoon cloves, grated
• ▢ 1 tablespoon light brown sugar , for the glass rim (optional)
• ▢ 1 tablespoon eggnog, for the glass rim (optional)

All my recipes are written both in Metric (gram / ml) and US Customary (cups / pounds). Here you can select which type of amount you would like to see.

Instructions

Prepare Your Dutch Spicy Eggnog

• ▢
  In a large mixing bowl, combine the advocaat, whisky, Kahlua, and rum. Whisk these liquids thoroughly until they are well-integrated and the mixture is smooth.
• ▢
  Add the freshly grated cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves to the liquid mixture. Continue to whisk vigorously for another minute or two, ensuring all the spices are evenly distributed and the mixture becomes slightly frothy.

Rim and Garnish Your Glasses (Optional)

• ▢
  If desired, prepare your serving glasses by pouring a small amount (about 1 tablespoon) of eggnog into a shallow dish. Gently dip the top rim (and a small portion of the outside edge) of each glass into the eggnog to moisten.
• ▢
  Next, immediately turn the moistened glass upside down and gently press its rim into a separate bowl containing light brown sugar. Rotate the glass slightly to ensure an even coating, creating a beautiful sugar ring. Repeat this process for all your serving glasses.
• ▢
  Carefully pour the chilled spicy Dutch eggnog into the prepared glasses. For a final flourish, sprinkle a pinch of freshly grated nutmeg on top of each serving. Serve immediately and enjoy this festive and unique holiday cocktail!

Notes

• Dip the top of the glass in a bit of egg nog and then in fine sugar. The sugar rim will get the same golden shine as the drink and that looks beautiful.
• Freshly grated nutmeg gots so much more flavor as the already grounded sort. So if you can get it, buy a whole nutmeg and grate it when needed in dishes.
• If you don’t have Kahlua, you can use Tia Maria, Sheridan’s or any other coffee Licor.
• If you want even more Winter flavors substitute cinnamon, nutmeg and cloves with 3 teaspoons gingerbread spices.
• Do you have some leftover egg nog? Use it to prepare a pudding, ice cream, and cake. Or you can use it for flavoring a cup of coffee or in a milkshake.

Nutrition

Calories: 387kcal
Carbohydrates: 29g
Protein: 6g
Fat: 6g
Saturated Fat: 4g
Cholesterol: 76mg
Sodium: 74mg
Fiber: 1g
Sugar: 28g
Vitamin A: 258IU
Vitamin C: 2mg
Iron: 1mg

Keyword
a cocktail for Christmas recipe, Dutch eggnog, homemade eggnog, spicy eggnog, holiday drink, advocaat cocktail

Tried this recipe?

Let us know how it was!